Saturday, November 21, 2026

BOOK REVIEW: Angel Down by Daniel Kraus

My historical fiction/history book group picked Angel Down by Daniel Kraus, a Pulitzer Prize winner, for our next meeting.

I have mixed feelings about the novel. It’s a fast read, especially in the middle, when I was curious to see what would happen next. It has an interesting premise. But it isn’t a book I particularly enjoyed. It’s set during WWI, but doesn’t need to be. Its wartime setting is pretty generic with leaders who don’t know what they’re doing and battlefields littered with dead. The story’s protagonist is Cyril Bagger, who has thus far managed to find relative safety as a gravedigger rather than a fighter on the front lines. But when their location is bombed, and his company retreats, Cyril and four others are ordered to find “the shrieker.” This is presumed to be a soldier out in no-man’s land dying slowly, painfully, and loudly. And they are to put him out of his misery.

Instead of a dying man, Bagger finds an angel. Or, if not an angel, some other sort of magical creature that he believes to be an angel. The novel focuses on how the men deal with this. (Spoiler alert- not very well.)

The book is very self-consciously literary, written as one long sentence. Every paragraph begins with the word “and”. The never-ending sentence is meant to mimic the never-ending war. It’s easy enough to read once you get used to it. More problematic (for me) was the gore porn. I didn’t realize that the novel is billed as horror, historical horror, which wouldn’t have been a choice of mine if it wasn’t a book club pick. After a while, the gore took on a cartoonishly exaggerated character and the shock value of more intestines, more spilled brains, and more starving men eating rats was lost. Are we supposed to become desensitized to it, the way people in wartime become desensitized to violent death? Maybe.

The book unraveled a bit at the end, as though the author wasn’t sure how to wrap things up. It had some Dickensian ghosts of Christmas Past and Christmas Future vibes, though without the redemption.

This novel is getting great reviews and blurbs, and did win a Pulitzer, so I’m clearly in the minority for finding it “meh.” Because of the touch of magical realism, I came away without a sense of the real, and without much of a connection to the characters. For a novel of WWI that truly gutted me, I would recommend All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque instead.

No comments:

Post a Comment