BOOK REVIEW: Loot by Tania James

For my next read, I dove into my TBR pile and pulled out Loot by Tania James, purchased in 2023 at a local indie bookstore’s signing event.

Set largely in 18th-century India, during the reign of Tipu Sultan of Mysore, it tells the story of an automaton (which did actually exist) representing a tiger mauling an Englishman. In the novel, the automaton, commissioned by Tipu, is built by a local young woodcarver/toy maker (Abbas) and a French expat clock maker (Lucien Du Leze.) When the British attack Mysore and overthrow Tipu, the automaton is seized as spoils of war and taken to an English estate where it joins a collector’s host of artifacts from the empire.

Abbas leaves Mysore to follow Du Leze, hoping to learn more about clock- and automaton-making. The journey is more difficult than he anticipated, and the unexpected awaits him, forcing him down a different path. (I’m going for no spoilers here.)

This is an interesting novel that took me to places I’d never been before. It is told from different character viewpoints, and some of the characters appear and disappear to move the plot along, without leaving much of an emotional trace. The central characters, Abbas and Du Leze, are more deeply explored. The novel picks up at the end with a love story, the seeds of which had been planted early on.

This novel is recommended for those interested in the complex and untoward ripple effects of British colonialism.

BOOK REVIEW: A Bitter Cut by Anna Lee Huber

I received this book for free from Netgalley. That did not influence this review.

The latest book (book 14, including a novella) in Anna Lee Huber’s Lady Darby Mysteries series is A Bitter Cut. Huber continues to serve up tightly plotted murder mysteries to be solved by the clever Lady Darby and her handsome husband, Sebastian Gage. And there are intricate family dynamics to navigate along the way.

In this book, Kiera (Lady Darby) and Gage are hosting a house party alongside Sebastian’s father, Lord Gage. There is to be a gathering of family and politically minded friends and acquaintances. For Kiera, the most critical partygoers are her brother Trevor, the young heiresss–Matilda Birnam--he hopes to wed, and Matilda’s parents. The parents, unfortunately, are nightmares. Not only are they commoners, but Mr. Birnam is pressing an unpopular political stance: allowing his factories to continue to exploit child labor. He dominates every table conversation despite the obvious distaste of his fellow diners. His wife, Mrs. Birnam, is a haughty, complaining shrew. If that isn’t bad enough, Mr. Birnam has brought along his secretary, a pretty young woman, whose presence he insists upon during social functions, despite the fact that this just isn’t done. (Is she his mistress, being foisted upon them all? Kiera is horrified.)

Before Kiera can get too worked up about the impropriety, the woman asks her to meet someplace private, at midnight, because she is frightened and has something to confess. When Kiera goes to meet her, she finds that the woman has been murdered. By way of an acid attack.

Once again, Kiera and Gage are called upon to solve what at first seems an unsolvable murder. What makes it even more difficult is the fact that the Birnams (who might possibly be future in-laws) and even her beloved brother Trevor are all hiding something.

Alongside the mystery, the novel delves into issues of inequality and child labor in mid-1800s England. As always, the Lady Darby Mysteries spin a fine tale.

BOOK REVIEW: The Daffodil Days by Helen Bain

I received this book for free from Netgalley. That did not influence this review.

I was interested in this novel when I read that it was about Sylvia Plath. It wasn’t because I am a particular Plath fan, but more that I like stories about writers in general. My knowledge of Plath (what I thought I knew) was that she was a poet and novelist, with a husband, Ted Hughes, who was also a poet, who was possibly a philanderer, but who was definitely jealous of her talent and was not supportive of her work. And I knew she took her own life while still quite young.

The Daffodil Days by Helen Bain takes the reader to the English countryside, to the small rural village of North Tawton, where Sylvia and Ted bought a farmhouse and a couple of acres to escape the hustle and bustle of London. (This is true.) They renovated the house and, with help, raised bees and played at being countryfolk.

What makes this story interesting is that it is not told from either Sylvia’s or Ted’s viewpoint. Instead, it is a stitched-together quilt introducing the reader to the residents of North Tawton, as well as to a few of Sylvia’s and Ted’s London friends who come to visit. These characters all share their impressions of Sylvia with the reader and with each other. It’s a gossipy book. But the portrayal of Sylvia, her charm, her brittleness, her scattered interests, her determination to have people see her as a writer equal in talent to her husband (who at that time was the more famous) is all the more intense and realistic because of the way very different people see her. There is wonder and a sympathy for her, but the reader does get the sense that there is something a little bit off about her. (And knowing her future makes this all the more poignant.) It also shows Ted as supportive, caring, but maybe a bit out of his depth in trying to help Sylvia as she pulls people in, then pushes them away.

I was a few chapters in before I realized something else. The story is told in reverse. It starts in December, 1962, after Sylvia and Ted have left the farmhouse. Then the chapters unfold in reverse chronological order to their purchase of the house in July, 1961. And so, we see the gossip about events before seeing the actual events.

This structure works exquisitely. This is a beautiful novel, highly recommended whether you are a Sylvia Plath fan or not.

BOOK REVIEW: Lady Tremaine by Rachel Hochhauser

Lady Tremaine by Rachel Hochhauser is a buzzed-about book that deserves the hype (IMHO).

This re-imagining of Cinderella turns the tale inside out by taking the part of the evil stepmother. It turns out, Lady Etheldreda Verity Isolde Tremaine Bramley is not evil. She is a woman caught between two worlds. She is, first and foremost, a mother who wants what is best for her two daughters, but has blinders on as to what is truly best. And she is a stepmother who reaches out to her stepdaughter, who tries to be empathetic, but who can’t help resenting a girl who won’t meet her halfway. “Cinderella” is the one who rejects her new family, not the other way around.

The novel uses the framework of the old tale, but fleshes out the characters (Lady Tremaine, her two daughters, Mathilde and Rosamunde, and the Cinderella figure, Elin) so that they are far more complex than purely evil versus purely good. There is no magic, only hard work. Prince Charming’s charm is false. And a long-ago rivalry between Lady Tremaine and the queen (Prince Charming’s mother) has far-reaching implications.

The prose is beautiful. The imagery of the danger of the forest and the parallels between falconry and motherhood elevate the story beyond a simple retelling. And the tension woven throughout make it unputdownable.

BOOK REVIEW: Fables and Lies by Elisabeth Storrs

I received this book for free from Netgalley. That did not influence this review.

Another WWII novel? This time, my excuse is that Fables and Lies was written by an author whose work I enjoy, Elisabeth Storrs. (Here are reviews of The Wedding Shroud, The Golden Dice, and Call to Juno, set in Ancient Rome and Etruria.)

This time, Storrs places her characters in Berlin during WWII. The story, based on real life events, focuses on Freya Bremer, an Aryan beauty brought up under a broken education system that emphasized Germany’s preeminent place in Western civilization. Her indoctrination into National Socialist ideology is nearly complete. Freya is intelligent, but naive. She has a secretarial job in a Berlin archeological museum, the one holding Heinrich Schleimann’s treasures from Troy, and dreams of one day taking part in excavations herself. But with the coming of the war, her job, along with others at the museum, becomes one of protecting Germany’s treasures (many of which were looted from other countries.) Throughout the war, with (or despite) the massive bombing campaign against Berlin, she strives to help save these ancient relics.

This is not a WWII tale of heroic resistance fighters, daring spies, or of Germans of conscience hiding Jews in their basements. It’s a story of sadistic, seemingly deranged Nazis, drunk with power, and of everyday citizens accommodating the evil in their midst in order to live their lives. The risks and fear are very real. Storrs does a fine job of showing how trapped many felt, and, realistically, how increasingly difficult it was to fight against the Nazi regime.

Freya is married to an abusive SS officer, Kaspar, who gives her and her family some protection, even some privilege. But she is in love with another man, Darien Lessing. Darien is an archeologist whom she met at the museum. Darien disabuses her of her naive assumptions of Aryan supremacy and opens her eyes to the abuses of the Nazis. And yet, he too is trapped by the system.

It is a painful book to read. Parallels with current day authoritarianism and Nazism show the slippery slope between looking the other way and complicity. It shows the level of denial when atrocities are taking place, even as the evidence becomes impossible to ignore.

The details of life in Berlin during the bombings and of how precious artifacts were given priority make this novel unique. Storrs’ meticulous research and powerful storytelling make it worthwhile.

BOOK REVIEW: The Lilac People by Milo Todd

I keep thinking no more WWII historical fiction because I’ve read so much of it. But then another comes along that I want to read. What is especially compelling is a word-of-mouth recommendation from a friend. So I added The Lilac People by Milo Todd to my TBR-pile.

This is a powerful and important novel that, in the current climate, hits very hard. In the immediate pre-WWII era, Berlin was a safe space for the LGBTQ+ community. They had a vibrant nightlife. But even more critically, there was an Institute of Sexual Science, led by Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld, where all facets of human sexuality were studied. (Unfortunately, this also led to the creation of a registry of “third sex” members of the community, which was a bonanza for the Nazis when they set out to exterminate these vulnerable people.)

The book uses the language of the times, when transgender people were called transvestites, which is not an acceptable term today. The protagonist of the novel, Bertie, is a trangender man, who works at the Institute as a clerk and sometimes tour guide. The book goes back and forth between 1945, the immediate aftermath of the war, and 1932-33, when queer people were targeted, killed in the streets, or rounded up to be sent to concentration camps. Bertie witnesses the violence, but is able to escape with his girlfriend to a farm out in the countryside when the parents of a friend take them in. The friend, Gert, was supposed to meet them there, but didn’t, and part of the heart of the book is the question of what happened to him. Was he killed? Sent to a concentration camp? Or might he have escaped to America?

The tension in the chapters sent in the early 30s is intense. Readers know what is coming under Hitler, while those living through it are blinded by a belief that things can’t get that bad, until they do. Then it’s too late.

But even more horrifying is the aftermath. I didn’t know that when the camps were liberated by the Allies, the prisoners were freed EXCEPT for those wearing pink or black triangles. LGBTQ+ prisoners were pulled aside and sent on to other prisons – by the Allies – for being “convicted criminals.”

Bertie learns this when he finds a half-dead Dachau escapee collapsed in his garden. Karl, a trans man, had been imprisoned at Dachau and managed to run when he saw fellow queer prisoners being segregated out for further incarceration. Bertie knows now they are still not safe.

At the same time, the Allies are determined to punish the German population for their crimes. By virtue of the fact that Bertie and his girlfriend, Sophia, had not been imprisoned, they are now under suspicion as being Nazis. The American soldiers are rounding up German civilians to transport them to work camps. Bertie is between a rock and a hard place.

The novel is heart-rending. At times, it does get a bit preachy and teachy, when one or another character monologues to get the message across. But it’s an important message, well worth spelling out. This novel is highly recommended.

BOOK REVIEW: The Dove and the Rogue by Harper St. George

 I received this book for free from Netgalley. That did not influence this review.

The Dove and the Rogue is the third book in Harper St. George’s The Doves of New York series, but it can also be read as a standalone.

The Dove sisters are three American heiresses who, by the terms of their father’s will, can only receive their inheritances if they marry into Britain’s aristocracy. Although the requirement is inconvenient, Jenny Dove, the middle sister, is less interested in the inheritance than in making her own way as an opera singer. However, her younger sister has fallen in love with a commoner and needs the money. Jenny feels if she fulfils the requirement, she can convince their guardian to release their inheritances.

Jenny has just the aristocrat in mind. Lord David, who is heir to a dukedom, is the worst rake in the ton. He has been flirting with her outrageously ever since she and her sisters arrived. So she offers him a deal. If he marries her, she’ll grant him one night in her bed. Then she’ll go off to Paris to star in a new opera, and he can continue living his life as he always has. In a short period of time, they’ll divorce, so that he will be free to marry someone more suitable for a future duke.

Lord David, who has grown obsessed with Jenny, agrees. But one passionate night together is not enough. Is it just lust they feel for one another, or something more?

This is an extra-steamy Victorian romance with the marriage of convenience and reformed rake tropes that should appeal to romance readers who like their stories hot.